Franck, James, 1882-1964

Hide Profile

James Franck was born August 26, 1882 in Hamburg, Germany, where his Sephardic Jewish forebears had lived for over two hundred years [Box 20, folder 58 and Box 21, folder 1]. His father, Jacob Franck, was a banker who wanted his son to follow a business career in keeping with family tradition. From childhood on, however, James could imagine no other life but science. An X-ray photograph illustrates his fascination with new discoveries in physics. He had already read of Roentgen's X-ray photography when he broke his arm in 1896. A mere boy of thirteen, he went alone to a municipal physics laboratory for a demonstration of Roentgen's discovery on his broken arm, which he later proudly recalled was the first use of X-ray in Hamburg [Box 21, folder 9]. Despite these scientific interests, Franck was considered a very dull schoolboy, for success within the curriculum of the classical gymnasium depended on one of his weakest faculties, rote memory.

In his first year of studies at Heidelberg, 1901, Franck met Max Born and others who shared his love of science. Born helped him persuade his parents to let him study physics, although at that time a scientific career offered little financial security. In 1902, he went to Berlin to study at the Friedrich Whilhelm University with some of Germany's most famous physicists, including Max Planck, whose formulation of the quantum in 1900 had given the new mechanics its names, and Emil Warburg, who became his thesis advisor. Among the remains from his student days are his notes of Planck's lectures, entitled "Mechanik nach Planck." [Box 11, folders 1 and 3 (Notebook 2).}

After earning a doctorate in physics in 1906 and spending a few months as a research assistant at Frankfurt am Main, Franck returned to the University of Berlin to work with Heinrich Rubens. Berlin became the setting for important personal as well as professional developments in Franck's life. There he met a talented pianist, Ingrid Josephson of Göteborg, Sweden, whom he married on December 23, 1907 [Box 21, folder 5]. Two daughters were born of this marriage, Dagmar on October 2, 1909, and Elisabeth on December 19, 1911.

In 1911, James Franck and Gustav Hertz began the study of elastic collisions between electrons and atoms. Their work led to the discovery of excitation potentials, the amount of energy which an electron must absorb before it can move further away from the nucleus of the atom. Two laboratory notebooks, stamped "Dr. G. Hertz," contain data from some of these experiments [Box 11, folders 7, 8, and 9 (Notebooks 5 and 6)].

The outbreak of World War I in 1914 ended the collaboration of Franck and Hertz. Both joined the German army. For his war service, Franck received the Iron Cross, first and second class, and the Hanseatic Cross of his native city, Hamburg [Box 21, folders 13 through 15]. His front line service ended in 1916 when he contracted severe polyneuritis affecting his legs [Box 21, folder 12].

After the war, Franck joined the faculty of the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Physical Chemistry in Berlin, where he continued the experiments which he had begun earlier with Gustav Hertz. Franck's work in this period is represented by three folders of data from helium experiments he conducted with Paul Knipping and Fritz Reiche [Box 11, folders 10 through 12]. In their November 1, 1919, article in Physikalische Zeitscrift reporting some of the findings of these helium experiments, Franck and Knipping added to the vocabulary of physics the term "metastable" to describe an atom in a condition of marginal stability.

It was during these postwar years in Berlin that Franck met Niels Bohr and realized for the first time that the Franck-Hertz experiments of 1911-1914 provided the first experimental evidence for Bohr's revolutionary and highly controversial atomic theory published in 1913. A lifelong friendship between Franck and Bohr developed from the respect the two scientists held for each other's work. The Franck-Bohr correspondence dates from October 19, 1920 to 1962, the year of Bohr's death [Box 1, folder 5].

Franck went to Göttingen in 1921 as professor physics and director of the Second Physics Institute. The years he spent there were among the happiest and most productive of his life. He was fortunate to have as colleagues Max Born and Robert Pohl, physicists who were also his longtime friends. Born, who had encouraged Franck to study physics when they were students at Heidelberg in 1901 and 1902, accepted the post of professor of theoretical physics at Göttingen in 1920 on the condition that Franck be offered a professorship for experimental physics [Box 21, folder 58]. Pohl, who had been a student with Franck in Berlin, held the professorship of experimental physics at the First Physics Institute [Box 20, folder 1 (1905 photograph)].

Franck, Born, and Pohl attracted some of the best young physicists in Germany to Göttingen. Among Franck's students and assistants whose correspondence is preserved in the collection are Günther Cario, Whilhelm Hanle, Gerhard Herzberg, Arthur von Hippel, Fritz G. Houtermans, Werner Kroebel, Hans Kopfermann, Heinrich G. Kuhn, Walter Lochte-Holtgreven, Rienhold Mannkopf, Heinz Maier-Leibnitz, Otto Oldenberg, Eugene Rabinowitch, and Hertha Sponer. [Arthur von Hippel married Dagmar, the elder of Franck's two daughters, in 1930]. The reputation of the Physics Institutes also drew many foreign students. Of those who worked with James Franck, two Englishmen, Patrick M. S. Blackett and Robert d'E. Atkinson, and three Americans, Francis Wheeler Loomis, Louis A. Turner, and J. Gibson Winans, are represented in the Franck correspondence. The mood of these Göttingen years is caught in an album of photographs kept by Hertha Sponder, Franck's research assistant at Göttingen [Box 19]. The pictures in Miss Sponer's album of group outings, parties at local inns, and afternoon coffees evoke the warmth and informality of Franck's relationships with his students.

Franck's international reputation was established during his years at the Second Physics Institute. In November, 1926, he received word that he and Gustav Hertz were to receive the 1925 Nobel Prize in physics. With this award, the Swedish Academy of Science gave recognition to the Franck-Hertz experiments which had led to the "discovery of the laws governing the collisions of electrons [with atoms]." [Box 5, folder 9]. The Franck Papers contain the Nobel certificate [Box 23, folder 4] and Franck's gold Nobel medal, as well as pictures of James and Ingrid Franck and Gustav and Ellen Hertz traveling to Stockholm and of the presentation ceremony on December 10, 1926 [Box 22. In 1934, Franck placed his Nobel medal in an office safe at Niels Bohr's Institute for Theoretical Physics in Copenhagen, and apparently forgot to reclaim it when he emigrated to America the following year. The medal remained in the safe until April, 1940, when, to keep it from the invading German army, George de Hevesy converted it to powder along with Bohr's Nobel medal. In 1950, Bohr sent the gold dust from the two medals to the Nobel Foundation for recasting (Box 5, folder 9). At the presentation of the recast medal in 1951, Franck said: "I am so delighted about this, as I know now that half of my medal is Niels Bohr's." (Victor Weisskopf, verbal communication to Elisabeth Lisco, October, 1974.) [Box 20, folders 7 through 14]. The Papers contain no scientific manuscripts or notebooks produced at Göttingen or reflecting Franck's distinguished work during that period.

The course of James Franck's life was radically altered in 1933 by the enactment, under the national socialist government, of laws removing Germans of Jewish descent from government positions. Franck's war record made him eligible for an individual exemption from this provision of the Jewish exclusion laws and would have allowed him, despite his Jewish background, to remain director of the Second Physics Institute. As director, however, he would have been required to take part in the dismissal of Jewish assistants and students. In a letter to the Minister of Culture, dated April 17, 1933, he resigned both his professorship and the directorship of the Second Physics Institute in protest of "the position of the government toward German Jews." [Box 7, folder 4]. Because of Franck's statures as a veteran of World War I and a Nobel laureate, his resignation created a sensation. In the following days and weeks he received many letters of praise and support for his stand not only from friends and colleagues but also from strangers [ Box 7, folders 5 through 7].

Franck's desire to continue his scientific work in Germany proved impossible. Months of searching failed to turn up a suitable position which would not require political compromises. At the end of 1933 he left Germany for America to accept a temporary appointment as Speyer Professor of Physics at Johns Hopkins University.

In 1934, Franck returned to Europe as a guest professor in Niels Bohr's laboratory at the Institute for Theoretical Physics, Copenhagen. Bohr attracted to the Institute many of the best German physicists of the mid-1930's, both Jews and non-Jews, who were leaving the German institutes then deteriorating under the Jewish exclusion laws and the Nazi attack on "Jewish" science [For example, see Box 7, folder 4, "German Physics and Jewish Physics," Volkischer Beobachter, February 28, 1936 [ A group photograph shows the remarkable wealth of scientific talent gathered in Copenhagen in 1935; seated beside James Franck in the front row of a lecture hall are Otto Stern, Lise Meitner, Max Born, Werner Heisenberg, Pascual Jordon, and Wolfgang Pauli. During his stay in Copenhagen Franck performed experiments with Hilde Levi on the fluorescence of chlorophyll [Box 20, folder 21]. Four notebooks from these experiments are preserved in the Franck papers [Box 11, folders 13 through 16].

Franck returned as a professor of physics to Johns Hopkins in 1935 where, for the next three years, he taught and continued his research on the fluorescence of chlorophyll. The small amount of material from his work at Baltimore consists of three folders of lecture notes,[ Box 12, folders 2 through 4] one notebook of laboratory data, [Box 12, folder 1 (Notebook 14)] and two folders of drafts and notes [Box 12, folders 14 and 15].

In 1938 Franck accepted an invitation to become professor of physical chemistry at the University of Chicago, where a special laboratory, supported by the Samuel S. Fels Fund of Philadelphia, was established for his photosynthesis research. The outbreak of World War II in 1939, however, cast a shadow on this promising beginning. As the war progressed, Franck considered the German fascist threat so grave that he laid aside his photosynthetic work to support the war effort. Despite misgivings about the atomic bomb's potential for destruction, he joined the Manhattan Project on December 1, 1942, one day before the first self-sustaining, controlled nuclear reaction was achieved. He directed the Chemistry Division of the Metallurgical Laboratory at the University of Chicago until December, 1943, when he began gradually to disengage himself from the project by becoming associate director, then serving as a consultant from May 1, 1944, until July 1, 1945.

The unprecedented destructive capability of the atomic bomb continued to trouble Franck as well as many other scientists who had helped create it. In 1944, when the main activity of the Manhattan Project had shifted to Los Alamos, Chicago became a center of discussion about the consequences of the bomb's impending use. During the summer and fall of that year, Franck served on a committee chaired by Zay Jeffries which solicited from group leaders at the scattered project sites opinions for a report on the future of nuclear energy. The "Jeffries Report," formally entitled "Prospectus on Nucleonics," was given to Arthur Compton on November 18, 1944, who forwarded it to General Leslie Groves [Box 18, folder 11] In the spring of 1945, Franck directed a personal appeal to the executive branch of the federal government in a memorandum he wrote with Eugene Rabinowitch [ Box 18, folder 13] On April 21, he delivered this memorandum to Secretary of Commerce Henry A. Wallace at a breakfast meeting in Washington arranged by Arthur Compton.

The following June, Franck chaired a committee composed of six other members of the Metallurical Laboratory (Eugene Rabinowitch, Leo Szilard, Joyce Clennam Stearns, Glenn T. Seaborg, James Joseph Nickson, and Donald J. Hughes) which produced a second memorandum on the social and political implications of atomic energy [Box 18, folder 23]. The "Franck Report," the name by which this memorandum became known, was a further development of the April 21 memorandum. J. J. Nickson's handwritten notes on a Franck Committee meeting in early June outline the ideas contributed by individual members of the committee [Box 18, folder 15]. At Franck's request, Rabinowitch drafted the report [Box 18, folder 18] and D. J. Hughes, Glenn T. Seaborg, and Robert S. Mulliken (who was not on the Franck Committee) wrote criticisms of it [Box 18, folder 21]. Although Rabinowitch, more than any other individual, was the author of the "Franck Report," it was essentially a group effort, summarizing months of informal discussion among Metallurgical Laboratory scientists on the implications of their work.

Franck traveled to Washington on June 11 to present the report at the office of the Secretary of War, Henry Stimson, in hopes of preventing the military use of the atomic bomb against Japan [Alice Kimball Smith, A Peril and A Hope: The Scientists' Movement in America, 1945-1947. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1965. p 14-48]. Although the recommendations of the "Franck Report" went unheeded, it became a symbol of awareness among scientists of the political and social impact of their discoveries. For Franck, the report was the product of a bitter lesson he had learned in Germany-that he could not afford to be apolitical. He expressed this insight in a letter written to German Ambassador Knappstein in 1964: "What has happened in our lifetime stems, I believe, from the fact that the people as a whole have left the solution of political questions chiefly to the government." [Box 3, folder 8 (German Embassy correspondence)].

World War II significantly altered Franck's personal life. Initially, it severed his lines of communication with Germany by curtailing the extensive correspondence he had carried on with German friends and colleagues since his emigration in 1935. At the same time, it strengthened his commitment to his American citizenship, which he received in July, 1941. In a letter written to the Baden Minister of Education in response to the offer of an appointment at Heidelberg after the war, Franck explained that his new allegiance made it impossible to consider returning to Germany: "I took this step, as soon as it was legally possible, not only to free myself from enforced statelessness, but also because I earnestly wanted to create a new homeland here. I have neither the wish to go back on this step, nor would I consider it justified." [Box 3, folder 12 (Heidelberg Universität correspondence)].

The close of the war enabled Franck to resume his correspondence with friends and former colleagues in Germany. Just as before the war many German Jews had turned to him for help in finding new jobs abroad, now many non-Jewish Germans asked him for money, food, and clothing. Franck responded generously out of his modest salary. The CARE packages Franck sent to his former teacher, Max Planck, occasioned an especially poignant exchange of letters in 1946 and 1947, for the frail and aged Planck had lost everything in the war, including his favorite son executed by the Nazis [Box 6, folder 4].

The reestablishment of contact with former friends who had stayed in Nazi Germany was sometimes painful. Franck was asked to understand and forgive compromises with totalitarianism and to vouch to the Occupation authorities for the character and conduct of men with whom he had not communicated for years. In a letter written May 26, 1947, to Eugene Wigner, Franck expressed his dilemma: "Within my narrow limits, I try to help everyone whose behavior I know was decent….After all that happened and after so many disillusionments about people whom I trusted in earlier times, I take nothing for granted anymore; now I have to know that those I trust are deserving of it." [Box 10, folder 5].

Despite his feelings of having been betrayed by some Germans whom he had considered friends, Franck remained open to reconciliation with a reconstructed Germany. In 1945, he joined other German and Austrian émigrés in America in signing an appeal for the economic rebuilding of Germany as a prerequisite to its moral recovery [Box 18, folder 26]. In the same spirit, he accepted German gestures of restitution. He agreed to rejoin the Göttingen Academy of Sciences, which had expelled him under fascist pressure in 1933, because, as he wrote to Theodore von Karman in a letter of February 11, 1948, "if one does not help the people who want to work for a future Germany free of nationalism and racism, etc. the chances for such a Germany to develop become practically zero." [Box 3, folder 8 (Göttingen Akademie der Wissenschaften correspondence)].

Immediately after the war, Franck was concerned not only with Germany, but also with the development and control of atomic energy in America. In the earliest days of the Cold War, the American government's policy of secrecy, designed to keep the technology of the atomic bomb from the Soviets, threatened to hinder research in atomic energy by suppressing the exchange of scientific information. Franck, with other scientists who had chafed under the security requirements of the Manhattan Project, was unwilling to see wartime restrictions continue in peace and sought to change the policy of secrecy in favor of international controls. To inform the American public of the issues, he became one of the founding members of the Atomic Scientists of Chicago, which on December 10, 1945, produced the first issue of the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists. But Franck remained uncomfortable with political activity, although he considered it imperative. Frustration at continued distraction from his work is expressed in a letter he wrote to Peter Pringsheim on September 13, 1945: "Against my wishes, I am again busy with discussions and plans on how to make it clear to the so-called statesmen and to the public what is at stake-that secrecy will not save the country and that a real world agreement is absolutely necessary; furthermore, that scientists are not obedient servants that one can muzzle at will…Damn it all! I really long for undisturbed concentration on scientific work." [Box 6, folder 7].

Franck returned to photosynthesis research after the interruptions of the war and post-war politics. Upon Frank's retirement in September, 1947, from his position as professor of physical chemistry at the University of Chicago, the University and the Samuel S. Fels Fund made arrangements to continue supporting his work. In 1948, the original ten-year Fels Fund grant was renewed for an indefinite period. Franck's photosynthesis laboratory was absorbed by the Institute of Radiobiology at the University of Chicago in July, 1949. The Fels Fund agreed in 1951 to provide a lifetime salary for Franck as director emeritus of the photosynthesis project [Box 2, folder 9] Hans Gaffron, Franck's research associate at the University of Chicago since 1939, assumed the directorship of the project in 1952.

Until his death in May of 1964, Franck continued to devote as much of his time as his health permitted to theoretical work on photosynthesis. He spent the winter months in Durham, North Carolina, with his second wife, Hertha Sponer-Franck, who had been a member of the Physics Department at Duke University since 1936. The Francks usually spent the summer at their house in Falmouth, Massachusetts. Each year, in the spring and fall, James Franck returned to Chicago for about a month in order to continue scientific discussions with his colleagues and to work on his publications. This pattern continued until about 1960, when Hans Gaffron moved the photosynthesis project from Chicago to Florida State University at Tallahassee. In collaboration with Jerome L. Rosenberg, Franck further developed his theoretical model of photosynthesis; a paper summarizing his ideas was finished shortly before he departed on his last journey to Europe in the spring of 1964 [See below, page 17].

Studies in Photosynthesis

From his first publication on photosynthesis in 1935, [Box 12, folder 14] Franck's attention focused on mechanisms by which quanta are absorbed and their energy transferred. Franck's interest in photosynthesis represents a logical progression from his pre-World War I studies leading to the discovery of excitation potentials of atoms. At Göttingen, Franck continued to study excitation potentials, using fluorescence to measure the conversion of excitation energy to other forms of energy. At the same time, biochemists and plant physiologists were just beginning to describe similar processes in plants, but the question of how light energy was transformed into energy utilizable by plants remained a mystery. In the early 1930's, observations of fluorescence in plant extracts were reported. As Franck became aware of these and other studies which paralleled his own work with fluorescence of free radicals in solution and of dye stuffs, he became increasingly interested in the question of energy conversion and transfer in plants [Although his major preoccupation from the 1930's on was photosynthesis, Franck did not completely abandon physics. A small group of manuscripts in the Franck Papers (Box 12, folder 5-13) relates to his publications in physics between 1935 and 1958, chiefly with Robert Platzman (Box 12, folder 6, 8, 10-11, 13), but also including one article with Edward Teller in 1938 (Box 12, folder 5) and one with his wife, Hertha Sponer in 1956 (Box 12, folder 12)].

Perhaps Franck's most enduring contribution to the advance of knowledge about photosynthesis is that his hypotheses and critiques stimulated other researchers to reconsider previously accepted theories, often resulting in the formulation of new theories [Roderick K. Clayton, Molecular Physics in Photosynthesis (New York: Blaisdell Publishing Company, 1965), p 182-91]. An example of this process is the effect of Franck's and Edward Teller's critique of the photosynthetic unit theory, published in the Journal of Chemical Physics in 1938, as part of an article on excitation energy in crystals [Box 12, folder 5]. The photosynthetic unit, as proposed by Robert Emerson and William Arnold in 1932 and modified by the reaction center hypothesis of Hans Gaffron and Kurt Wohl in 1936, was defined as a set about 2,000 chlorophyll molecules acting together with associated enzymes to reduce carbon dioxide and to produce glucose. The reaction center was postulated as the site in the photosynthetic unit where the light energy gathered by chlorophyll molecules is changed into chemical energy. In their 1938 article, Franck and Teller used quantum mechanical principles to distinguish among three types of energy transfer, later designated by Theodore Förster as "fast," "intermediate," and "slow." Each of these three types of energy transfer became an area of major research interest from which developed theoretical advances in the description of the size and organization of the photosynthetic unit and of its reaction center.

Frank's photosynthesis research under the first ten-year Fels Fund grant (1938-48) is represented in the Franck Papers by only two folders of manuscripts and notes [Box 12, folders 16 and 17]. Sometime after his retirement in September, 1947, Franck went through his files and disposed of his rough notes and drafts. Most of the manuscripts preserved in the Franck Papers date from the period after 1948 when Franck's need to conserve his energy for work on his publications left him no time for sorting and discarding his papers.

Franck's work on photosynthesis received greater attention after 1949, when he became involved in a bitter controversy [This controversy followed Franck to the grave when Warburg published, in Die Naturwissenschaften 23 (1964), pp. 550-51, a rebuttal to Wernre Kroebel's obituary of Franck, "Zum Tode von James Franck," Die Naturwissenschaften 18 (1964), pp. 421-23 (Box 21, folder 51)] with the German biochemist, Otto Warburg (the son of the Franck's thesis advisor, Emil Warburg) [See the tribute to Emil Warburg on his eighty-fifth birthday by James Franck and Robert Pohl, Box 21, folder 44]. The "Warburg controversy" centered on the quantum yield of photosynthesis, i.e., the measurement of the amount of light energy necessary to effect the primary photochemical act. Otto Warburg reported a quantum requirement of four quanta per carbon dioxide molecule for the process of photosynthesis. This requirement would have made photosynthesis a highly complex chemical reaction proceeding with virtually no friction at seventy-five per cent overall efficiency in the conversion of light energy into chemical energy. To Franck this finding was physically impossibly by the laws of thermodynamics and of the quantization of energy; four quanta could not effect the conversion. According to his interpretation of quantum theory, thermodynamics, and chemical kinetics, the requirement had to be at least eight quanta, and most experimentalists reported measurements of between six and ten. Warburg denied that these laws of physics applied to the living cell and stood by his measurements even though no other research groups could verify them. Warburg's obstinacy was particularly irritating to Franck, who characteristically would alter his photosynthetic model to take into account experimental data from other laboratories as well as his own.

In his 1949 article in Archives of Biochemistry, [Later the Archives of Biochemistry and Biophysics] Franck explained the disparity between quantum yields obtained by Robert Emerson at the University of Illinois and those of Warburg's group in Berlin by suggesting that Warburg was measuring the photochemical reduction of respiratory intermediates rather than normal photosynthesis [Box 12, folder 18 through 21]. Warburg not only refused to be persuaded, but also published new measurements which lowered the quantum requirement from four to two and seven-tenths quanta per carbon dioxide molecule. In a second article, appearing in the July, 1952 Archives of Biochemistry and Biophysics, Franck marshaled evidence for another attempt at convincing Warburg. The extensive notes and drafts of this article in the Franck Papers testify to the care Franck took in preparing it [Box 13, folders 1 through 29]. His closely reasoned essay provided a physical explanation for the reaction mechanisms of the Calvin-Benson cycle of carbon dioxide reduction and for the high quantum yields obtained by Warburg's research group.

One of Franck's arguments in this 1953 article illustrates his characteristic ability to keep in view, in the most complex discussions, consideration so simple and obvious that others tended to overlook them: Warburg's highest quantum yields occurred under conditions unfavorable to plant growth. Franck made this point about Warburg's technique with subtle humor: "In principle it is certainly justified to vary the conditions until the photochemical process works at its highest efficiency. However, the value of such variation becomes dubious if one finds that the photosynthetic apparatus can only be induced to do its 'best' under conditions where other tests show that the cells are not functioning well…Thus we find that high yields seem to be connected with influences generally regarded as harmful to the plants." [Box 13, folder 1, p. 26-27].

The Gatlinburg Conference on Photosynthesis held October 25-29, 1955, in eastern Tennessee, [Box 14, folders 1 through 13] was organized specifically to discuss the mechanism of the primary process of photosynthesis [Hans Gaffron, ed., Research in Photosynthesis (New York: Interscience Publishers, Inc., 1957), p. v-vi]. The quantum yield controversy was excluded from the conference agenda because it was stalemated. In the mid-1950's, there appeared to be no prospect of resolving the issue. It was only after Franck's death that Warburg was proven wrong.

Franck was unable to attend the Gatlinburg Conference which related so directly to his interests because of a heart attack. Before being stricken, however, he had prepared two papers for the conference on the theoretical implications of the experiments on the chemiluminescence of chlorella algae, which his young University of Chicago colleague, John E. Brugger, had performed for his dissertation research [Box 14, folder 6]. Brugger presented the first of Franck's two Gatlinburg papers, as well as two papers of his own. Robert Livingston of Minnesota presented Franck's second paper. One significant outcome of the Gatlinburg Conference was a book edited by Franck's co-worker Hans Gaffron, Research in Photosynthesis, containing all of the conference papers, and transcripts of a good portion of the ensuing discussions [Box 14, folders 4, 9-13] The papers of Franck and Brugger which were presented at Gatlinburg in 1955 were not summarized for publication in a journal until 1958, since Franck, with characteristic thoroughness, wanted to develop a theory encompassing all observed afterglow phenomena [Box 14, folders 11-33].

In 1955, Franck agreed to prepare a section of the Handbuch der Pflanzenphysiologie (Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1960) on the fluorescence of chlorophyll in relation to the primary processes of photosynthesis. He reluctantly undertook what was to become a major project because he did not want to see the article written by researchers whose ideas he did not respect. He was somewhat chagrined at his own motivation, as he explained to his collaborator on the project, Robert Livingston: "I feel in this matter like the dog who is willing to eat salad if only to prevent the other dog from getting it even if he dislikes it himself." [Box 9, folder 1 (Springer-Verlag correspondence)]. The lively and sometimes acrimonious debates sparked by photosynthesis research led Franck to take great care that his publications were as accurate and comprehensive as he could make them. The effort that went into the Handbuch article is clear from the large amount of material related to it in the Franck papers [Box 15, folders 1-21].

Toward the end of his life, James Franck's poor health increasingly frustrated his efforts to continue his work. He agreed to serve as a moderator at the Symposium on Light and Life sponsored by the McCollum-Pratt Institute of Johns Hopkins University; but, as he wrote to William D. McElroy in October, 1959: "My health is unreliable…I have the great wish to come to your meeting, and if you want me to be the moderator of Session II, I think that I could do that without undue stress on my health. However, I don't want to write a paper because I know by experience that to work for a deadline in writing papers is something which does me no good, and I took a solemn vow not to do it anymore. So my answer would be 'yes' with pleasure, but there is a risk involved for you that until March maybe my health will deteriorate." [Box 5, folder 3].

Franck was able to participate in the Symposium on Light and Life, however, which met in Baltimore, March 28-31, 1960. At this symposium, he became involved in a debate with University of California biochemist Melvin Calvin, regarding light activation in photosynthesis. Calvin insisted that the role of light in photosynthesis was limited to the photoionization of chlorophyll in chloroplasts, resulting in a migration of charged electrons and positive holes to a "solar battery" which then electrolyzed water. Franck found Calvin's thesis inadequate for explaining a number of experimental observations, including the Emerson effect, the doubling of fluorescence, the afterglow phenomena, and the chemical kinetics of photosynthesis rates under various external conditions [Box 15, folder 22. Franck's contributions to the discussions following the session which he moderated and to other symposium session are recorded in a book edited by William D. McElroy and Bentley Glass, A Symposium on Light and Life (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press, 1961)].

The Calvin controversy was the background for James Franck's last three publications in 1962, 1963, and 1964, which he wrote with Jerome L. Rosenberg of the University of Pittsburgh. Rosenberg had been at the University of Chicago from 1948 to 1950 on an Atomic Energy Commission post-doctoral fellowship. After the fellowship expired, he had stayed at the University with the photosynthesis project until 1953, when he was appointed to the Chemistry Department at the University of Pittsburgh. In 1961, 1962, and 1963, Franck spent some months working with Rosenberg in Pittsburgh. Their first article, "The Primary Photochemical Step in Photosynthesis: A Comparison of Two Theories," was published in Luminescence of Organic and Inorganic Materials (New York: John Wiley and Sons, Inc., 1962), under the editorship of Hartmut P. Kallman and Grace Marmor Spruch. This article dealt specifically with Franck's and Rosenberg's critique of Calvin's theory of light utilization.

Before Rosenberg left the United States in the summer of 1962 to spend his sabbatical year in Israel, he and Franck completed an article for the Journal of Theoretical Biology, which offered an alternative to Calvin's model of light utilization. On October 10, 1962, Franck wrote to Rosenberg to tell him that he had decided to withdraw their article for revision in view of new observations by Melvin Calvin, C. S. French, Warren Butler, and R. A. Olsen. He explained to Rosenberg the probable consequences when word of this got out: "I believe my reputation as an absolutely unreliable character will certainly be considerably enhanced among the biochemists…At least, there will not be many physical chemists who believe that someone's changing his mind is proof for utter lack of character. I personally regard it not as too bad a sign that at my age, I'm not incorrigible, but able to be slowly reformed." [Box 7, folder 10].

Franck and Rosenberg presented a short abstract of this article at a symposium sponsored by the Committee on Photobiology of the National Academy of Science-National Research Council, held at Airlie House in Warrenton, Virginia, October 14-18, 1963. Eugene Rabinowitch later recalled that Franck found very gratifying the serious and critical response which met his presentation at this symposium [Box 21, folder 61]. Subsequently the abstract appeared with other papers from the symposium in a book entitled Photosynthetic Mechanisms in Green Plants (Washington, D. C.: National Academy of Sciences-National Research Council, 1963). The revised article finally was published in the Journal of Theoretical Biology shortly before Franck's death in the spring of 1964.

Recognition of a Scientific Legacy

James Franck took a modest view of his scientific achievements. Talking on the pioneer era of quantum physics, at the International Conference on Luminescence, New York University, October 1961, he praised Max Planck, Albert Einstein, Niels Bohr, and Walther Nernst for opening the "new path," and described himself as one of those who "went along and picked flowers to the right and to the left which were growing in abundance." [Box 21, folder 9]. That his achievements were not esteemed so lightly by others is evident from the many honorary degrees, certificates of society membership, and medals preserved in the Franck Papers [Box 22 and Box 23, folder 4 through Box 24, folder 2].

Franck's self-effacing attitude toward many of the awards which came late in his life is expressed in a letter of August 21, 1963, to Robert Livingston: "In most cases, it [an honorary degree] is just a sign of old age." [Box 5, folder 1]. Several of the honors must have given him special satisfaction, however. He was deeply moved by the personal tributes from his friends, colleagues, and former students, collected by Robert Platzman, and presented in a leather-bound volume at the Franck summer house in Falmouth, Massachusetts on his seventieth birthday, August 26, 1952 [Box 23]. Also gratifying to him were the Rumford Medal awarded by the American Academy of Arts and Sciences in 1955 [See his letter to George Wald, Box 10, folder 1] and the Dannie-Heineman Prize given by the Göttingen Academy of Sciences in 1962. These two awards recognized his contributions to the understanding of photosynthesis which he often felt were not appreciated.

The receipt of honors sometimes provided occasions for trips to Germany to visit old friends. As he became frail, Franck recognized that each visit might be the last, and in the spring of 1964 he made his final trip abroad. The highlight of this trip was a Berlin reunion with colleagues from his days at the Friedrich Wilhelm University and the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute. With Lise Meitner, he visited Gustav Hertz in East Berlin, and then met briefly with Wilhelm Westphal in West Berlin. From Berlin, he took the train to Göttingen, where he died of a heart attack on May 21, 1964.

A James Franck Memorial Symposium on energy exchange in molecular systems, sponsored by the Department of Chemistry of the University of Chicago with the support of the Samuel S. Fels Fund, was held at the University on May 12-13, 1966. In the symposium's four scientific sessions, talks on physical chemistry were given by Gerhard Herzberg, William Klemperer, Edwin N. Lassettre, Lewis M. Branscomb, Alfred Kastler, and Mark G. Inghram; a talk on photochemistry was presented by G. S. Hammond, and one on photosynthesis by Eugene Rabinowitch. These talks acknowledged Franck's scientific legacy, as exemplified by current research in which his theories and methods were being employed. In a luncheon address on May 12, Rabinowitch spoke of Franck's political contributions, focusing on the best-known example, the "Franck Report." At dinner, Hans Gaffron and Edward Teller recalled Franck's remarkable personal qualities, as did Robert Pohl in a talk delivered for him by his son. All of the symposium talks and discussion were recorded on tapes, which are preserved in the Franck Papers [Box 19]. Photographs taken at the session of the Franck Memorial Symposium are included in the photograph collection [Box 20, folder 47-54].

On the occasion of this symposium, a volume of "selected papers" of James Franck was to have been published. For this project, Robert Platzman compiled a bibliography of Franck's published writings, selected a number of those works to be reprinted in the volume, and solicited from Franck's co-authors memoirs to introduce each paper [See Appendix, p. 124-34]. The correspondence, manuscripts, Platzman's annotate copy of the bibliography and related notes, and a set of photocopies of Franck's published articles are preserved in the Franck Papers [Box 24, folder 3 through Box 26, folder 4]. According to notes appended to his draft of the Franck bibliography, Platzman never was satisfied that the bibliography was comprehensive. Following the symposium, he continued to work on the Franck volume, but the project was left unfinished at his death in the summer of 1973 [Box 25, folders 5-9].

From the guide to the Franck, James. Papers, 1882-1966, (Special Collections Research Center University of Chicago Library 1100 East 57th Street Chicago, Illinois 60637 U.S.A.)

Archival Resources
Role Title Holding Repository
referencedIn Born, Max, 1882-1970. Oral history interview with Max Born, 1960 June to 18 October 1962. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Frisch, Otto Robert, 1904-. Oral history interview with Otto Robert Frisch, 1963 May 8. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
creatorOf Fajans, Kasimir, 1887-1975. Kasimir Fajans papers, 1912-1975. Bentley Historical Library
referencedIn Bohr, Niels, 1885-1962. Manuscripts, other authors, 1910-1961. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Hertz, Gustav, 1887-. Oral history interview with Gustav Ludwig Hertz, 1963 May 14 and 15. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Mayer, Maria Goeppert, 1906-1972. Oral history interview with Maria Goeppert Mayer, 1962 February 20. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Burger, Herman Carel, 1893-1965. Oral history interview with Herman Carel Burger, 1962 November 15. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
creatorOf Archive for the History of Quantum Physics, 1898-1950 (bulk), 1898-1950 American Philosophical Society
referencedIn Harold Clayton Urey Papers, 1929-1981 University of California, San Diego. Geisel Library. Mandeville Special Collections Library.
referencedIn Rabinowitch, Eugene, 1901-1973. Papers, 1945-1973 (inclusive). University of Chicago Library
referencedIn Darrow, Karl K. (Karl Kelchner), 1891-. Oral history interview with Karl K. Darrow, 1964 April 2 and 10 June. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Niels Bohr Library. The Emilio Segrè visual archives, E-J, [ca. 1870]-9999. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Compton, Betty Charity McCloskey, 1916-. Oral history interview with Betty Charity McCloskey Compton, 1968 April 11 and 14. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Wheeler, John Archibald, 1911-2008. Oral history interview with John Archibald Wheeler, 1988 May 4 to November 28. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Govindjee, 1932-. Eugene Rabinowitch: His life -- primarily based on an interview with him on January 5, 1964 at 1021 West Church, Champaign (mostly in his words). American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Inglis, David Rittenhouse, 1905-1995. Oral history interview with David Rittenhouse Inglis, 1977 May 9 and 10. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Friedman, Herbert, 1916-2000. Oral history interview with Herbert Friedman, 1980 August 21. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Lasarev, Petr Petrovich, 1878-1942. Papers, 1914-1941. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Reiche, F. (Fritz), 1883-1969. Papers, 1907-1998. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Martin David Kamen Papers, 1923 - 1992 University of California, San Diego. Geisel Library. Mandeville Special Collections Library.
referencedIn Albert Einstein College of Medicine. Miscellaneous bound volumes, [ca. 1954-1969]. Campbell University, Wiggins Memorial Library
referencedIn Stern, Otto, 1888-1969. Oral history interview with Otto Stern, 1962 May 29 and 1963 May 30. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Blackett, P. M. S. (Patrick Maynard Stuart), Baron Blackett, 1897-1974. Oral history interview with P. M. S. Blackett, 1962 December 17. American Institute of Physics
referencedIn Heitler, Walter, 1904-. Oral history interview with Walter Heitler, 1963 March 18 and 19. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn French, Charles Stacy, 1907-. Charles Stacy French papers, 1935-1989. Stanford University. Department of Special Collections and University Archives
referencedIn Oldenberg, Otto, 1888-1983. James Franck at Göttingen, ca. 1971. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Villars, Donald Statler, 1900-. Intellectual autobiography, 1964. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Rabinowitch, Eugene I. Papers, 1945-1972 Special Collections Research Center, University of Chicago Library,
referencedIn Andreĭ Sakharov papers, 1852-2002 (inclusive), 1960-1990 (bulk). Houghton Library
referencedIn Charles Stacy French papers, 1935-1989 Cecil H. Green Library. Department of Special Collections and University Archives
referencedIn Meissner, Karl Wilhelm, 1891-. Letters from Max Theodor Felix von Laue, James Franck, and Annamarie Bertel Schrödinger, 1939-1949. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Atomic Scientists of Chicago. Records, 1943-1955 (inclusive). University of Chicago Library
referencedIn Levi, Hilde. Oral history interview with Hilde Levi, 1971 October 28. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Heisenberg, Werner, 1901-1976. Oral history interview with Werner Heisenberg, 1962 November 30 to 12 July 1963. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Loeb, Leonard B. (Leonard Benedict), 1891-. Oral history interview with Leonard B. Loeb, 1962 August 7. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Platzman, Robert Leroy. Papers, 1944-1952. University of Chicago Library
referencedIn Lazarus, David, 1921-. Oral history interview with David Lazarus, 1981 December 4. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Ava Helen and Linus Pauling Papers, 1910-1994 (bulk 1922-1991) Oregon State University SpecialCollections & Archives Research Center, The ValleyLibrary
referencedIn Hanle, Wilhelm, 1901-. Oral history interview with Wilhelm Hanle, 1979 May 23 May to 2 June. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Klein, Oskar. Oral history interview with Oskar Benjamin Klein, 1962 September 25 to 16 July 1963. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn William B. Provine collection of evolutionary biology reprints, 20th century. Division of Rare and Manuscript Collections, Cornell University Library.
referencedIn Pohl, Robert Wichard, 1884-1976. Oral history interview with Robert Wichard Pohl, 1963 June 25. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Gerlach, Walther, 1889-1979. Oral history interview with Walther Gerlach, 1963 February 18 and 23. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn American Philosophical Society Library. Miscellaneous Manuscripts Collection. 1668-1983. American Philosophical Society
creatorOf Harold Clayton Urey Papers University of California, San Diego, UC San Diego Library; UCSD Library
referencedIn Oppenheimer, J. Robert, 1904-1967. Oral history interview with J. Robert Oppenheimer, 1963 November 18 and 20. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Meggers, William F. (William Frederick), 1888-1966. Home movies of William Meggers [motion picture] / taken by William Meggers. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Wigner, Eugene Paul, 1902-1995. Oral history interview with Eugene Paul Wigner, 1981 January 24. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
creatorOf Franck, James. Papers, 1882-1966 Special Collections Research Center, University of Chicago Library,
creatorOf Kasimir Fajans Papers, 1912-1987, 1936-1975 Bentley Historical Library
referencedIn Weisskopf, Victor Frederick, 1908-2002. Oral history interview with Victor Frederick Weisskopf, 1963 July 10. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
creatorOf Bohr, Niels Henrik David, 1885-1962. Typewritten letter signed : Copenhagen, to Professor James Franck, 1920 Oct. 18. Pierpont Morgan Library.
referencedIn Meitner, Lise, 1878-1968. Oral history interview with Lise Meitner, 1963 May 12. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Platzman, Robert Leroy. Papers, 1944-1952 Special Collections Research Center, University of Chicago Library,
referencedIn Nordheim, Lothar, 1899-. Oral history interview with Lothar Wolfgang Nordheim, 1962 July 30. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Atomic Scientists of Chicago. Records, 1943-1955 Special Collections Research Center, University of Chicago Library,
referencedIn Kasimir Fajans Papers, 1912-1987, 1936-1975 Bentley Historical Library
creatorOf Kamen, Martin David, 1913-2002. Papers, 1923-1992. University of California, San Diego, UC San Diego Library; UCSD Library
referencedIn Hund, Friedrich, 1896-1997. Oral history interview with Friedrich Hund, 1963 June 25 and 26. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Pohl, Robert Wichard, 1884-1976. Letters to James Franck, ca. 1920-ca. 1960. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
creatorOf Franck, James, 1882-1964. Reminiscences [sound recording] : an address at the American Physical Society, Southeastern Section, 1962 April 5. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Mayer, Joseph Edward, 1904-. Oral history interview with Joseph Edward Mayer, 1975 January 24. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Collections relating to history of physics and allied sciences. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Weizsäcker, Carl Friedrich, Freiherr von, 1912-2007. Oral history interview with Carl Friedrich Weizsacker, 1986 January 28. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Emergency Committee in Aid of Displaced Foreign Scholars. Emergency Committee in Aid of Displaced Foreign Scholars records. 1927-1949. New York Public Library. Manuscripts and Archives Division
creatorOf Franck, James, 1882-1964. Oral history joint interview with James Franck and Hertha Sponer-Franck, 1962 July 9 to 14. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Debye, Peter J. W. (Peter Josef William), 1884-1966. Papers, 1901-1906 and 1918-1945. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Kuhn, H. G. (Heinrich Gerhard), 1904-. Oral history interview with H.G. Kuhn, 1984 July 09. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Nordheim, Lothar, 1899-. Oral history interview with Lothar Wolfgang Nordheim, 1977 July 24. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Jordan, Pascual, 1902-1980. Oral history interview with Ernst Pascual Jordan, 1963 June 17 to 20. American Institute of Physics, Niels Bohr Library
referencedIn Niels Bohr Library. History of physics manuscript biography collection D-H, 1901-1989, [ca. 1960]-1989 (bulk) Campbell University, Wiggins Memorial Library
Role Title Holding Repository
Relation Name
associatedWith Abraham, Max, 1875-1922 person
associatedWith Abrahamsen, E. person
associatedWith Academic Assistance Council. corporateBody
associatedWith Academic Press. corporateBody
associatedWith Académie royale des sciences, des lettres et des beaux-arts de Belgique. corporateBody
associatedWith Ach, Narziss, 1871-1946 person
associatedWith Adams, Edwin Plimpton, 1878-1956 person
associatedWith Adrian, Edgar Douglas Adrian, Baron, 1889-1977 person
associatedWith Aerts, V. person
associatedWith Agassiz, Louis, 1807-1873 person
associatedWith Akademischer Verlag. corporateBody
associatedWith Albert Einstein College of Medicine. corporateBody
associatedWith Algemeen Nederlands Persbureau. corporateBody
associatedWith Algemene Nederlandse Vereniging voor Wijsbegeerte. corporateBody
associatedWith Allard, Georges person
associatedWith Allen, Herbert Stanley, 1873-1954 person
associatedWith Allen, J. F., (John Frank) person
associatedWith Allison, Samuel King, 1900-1965 person
associatedWith Amaldi, Edoardo, 1908-1989 person
associatedWith Ambassade van het Koninkrijk der Nederlanden. corporateBody
associatedWith American Academy of Arts and Sciences. corporateBody
associatedWith American Association for the Advancement of Science. corporateBody
associatedWith American Association of Physics Teachers. corporateBody
associatedWith American Chemical Society. corporateBody
associatedWith American Institute of Physics. corporateBody
associatedWith American Philosophical Society. corporateBody
associatedWith American Physical Society. corporateBody
associatedWith American Physical Society and American Philosophical Society. corporateBody
associatedWith American Physical Society. Southeastern Section. Meeting (1962 : Tallahassee, Fla.) corporateBody
associatedWith Andrade, E. N. da C., (Edward Neville da Costa), 1887-1971 person
associatedWith Andrews, Donald H., (Donald Hatch), 1898-1973 person
associatedWith Ankara Universitesi. corporateBody
associatedWith Arkel, A. E. van, (Anton Eduard), 1893-1976 person
associatedWith Arndt, Fritz, 1885-1969 person
associatedWith Arrhenius, Svante, 1859-1927 person
associatedWith Atkinson, Robert d'Escourt, 1898-1982 person
associatedWith Atomic Scientists of Chicago corporateBody
associatedWith Atomic Scientists of Chicago. corporateBody
associatedWith Auer von Welsbach, Carl, Freiherr von, 1858-1929 person
associatedWith Auger, Pierre, 1899-1993 person
associatedWith Aurén, Tycho Emanuel Ericson person
associatedWith Austria. Österreichische Bundesregierung. corporateBody
associatedWith Bacher, Robert F., (Robert Fox), 1905-2004 person
associatedWith Back, Ernst, 1881-1959 person
associatedWith Baedeker, Karl, 1877-1914 person
associatedWith Baerwald, Hans G. person
associatedWith Baeyer, Otto von, b. 1877 person
associatedWith Bagge, E. R., (Erich Rudolf), 1912-1996 person
associatedWith Baker, J. B. person
associatedWith Bakker, Cornelis Jan, 1904-1960 person
associatedWith Ballantine, Stuart, (Charles Stuart), 1897-1944 person
associatedWith Bangham, D. H. person
associatedWith Banks, Joseph, Sir, 1743-1820 person
associatedWith Bargmann, V., (Valentine), 1908-1989 person
associatedWith Barkhausen, G. H. person
associatedWith Barnes, John Landes, 1906-1976 person
associatedWith Barnett, Samuel Jackson, 1873-1956 person
associatedWith Barres, J. William person
associatedWith Bartlett, James H., (James Holley), 1904-2000 person
associatedWith Barton, Henry Askew, 1898-1983 person
associatedWith Baruch, Herman Benjamin, 1872-1953 person
associatedWith Bataafsche Petroleum Maatschappij. corporateBody
associatedWith Battelli, Angelo, 1862-1916 person
associatedWith Bauer, Edmond, 1880-1963 person
associatedWith Bauer, Friedrich Ludwig, 1924- person
associatedWith Bauman, J. person
associatedWith Baur, Emil, b. 1873 person
associatedWith Bazzoni, Charles B., (Charles Blizard), b. 1886 person
associatedWith Bechert, Karl, 1901-1981 person
associatedWith Bechmann, Rudolf person
associatedWith Becker, Richard, 1887-1955 person
associatedWith Becker, Wilhelm, 1907-1996 person
associatedWith Becquerel, Jean, 1878-1953 person
associatedWith Begle, Edward G., (Edward Griffith), 1914-1978 person
associatedWith Belgium. Ministerie van Buitenlandsche Zaken. corporateBody
associatedWith Belinfante, F. J., (Frederik Jozef) person
associatedWith Bell, H. person
associatedWith Bell, R. P., (Ronald Percy) person
associatedWith Bemolt van Loghum Slaterus, A. J., b. 1902 person
associatedWith Benedicks, Carl Axel Fredrik, 1875-1953 person
associatedWith Benndorf, Hans, 1870-1953 person
associatedWith Bergh, J. E. van den person
associatedWith Berg, Lewis E. person
associatedWith Bergmann, Ernst David, 1903-1975 person
associatedWith Berg, W. van den person
associatedWith Berlème, Aage person
associatedWith Berliner, Arnold, 1862-1942 person
associatedWith Bertotti, B., 1930- person
associatedWith Bethe, Hans A., (Hans Albrecht), 1906-2005 person
associatedWith Beth, Erich person
associatedWith Betz, Albert, 1885-1968 person
associatedWith Beutler, Hans, 1896-1942 person
associatedWith B.G. Teubner. (Firm) corporateBody
associatedWith Bhabha, Homi Jehangir, 1909-1966 person
associatedWith Bialobrzeski, Czeslaw person
associatedWith Bierens de Haan, J. A., (Johan Abraham), 1883-1958 person
associatedWith Biezeno, Cornelis Benjamin, 1888-1975 person
associatedWith Biggs, Henry Francis person
associatedWith Bijl, Arie person
associatedWith Bijl, D. person
associatedWith Birge, Raymond T. (Raymond Thayer), b. 1887. person
associatedWith Birkhoff, George David, 1884-1944 person
associatedWith Bitter, Francis, 1902-1967 person
associatedWith Bjerknes, V., (Vilhelm), 1862-1951 person
associatedWith Bjerrum, Niels, 1879-1958 person
associatedWith Bjørn-Andersen, H. person
associatedWith Blackett, P. M. S. (Patrick Maynard Stuart), Baron Blackett, 1897-1974. person
associatedWith Blackie and Son. corporateBody
associatedWith Blake, G. person
associatedWith Blanshard, Brand, 1892-1987 person
associatedWith Bloch, Felix, 1905-1983 person
associatedWith Blokhuis, K. person
associatedWith Blumenthal, Otto, 1876-1944 person
associatedWith Bôcher, Maxime, 1867-1918 person
associatedWith Bodea, Eugen person
associatedWith Bodewig, Ewald person
associatedWith Boer, Jan de, b. 1911 person
associatedWith Boeser, P. A. S. person
associatedWith Bohr, Aage Niels, 1922- person
associatedWith Bohr, Harald August, 1887-1951 person
associatedWith Bohr, Margrethe Nørlund person
associatedWith Bohr, Niels, 1885-1962. person
associatedWith Boltzmann, Ludwig, 1844-1906 person
associatedWith Bonhoeffer, Karl Friedrich, 1899-1957 person
associatedWith Bonino, Giovanni Battista, 1899-1985 person
associatedWith Bopp, Friedrich Arnold, 1909–1987 person
associatedWith Bork, Alfred M. person
associatedWith Born, Hedwig person
associatedWith Born, Max, 1882-1970. person
associatedWith Boston Society for Psychic Research. corporateBody
associatedWith Böttcher, C. J. F., (Carl Johan Friedrich), 1915-2008 person
associatedWith Bottema, O., (Oene) person
associatedWith Bourgin, David Gordon, b. 1900 person
associatedWith Boutry, G. A., (Georges Albert) person
associatedWith Bouwkamp, C. J., (Christoffel Jacob) person
associatedWith Bowen, Ira Sprague, 1898-1973 person
associatedWith Bragg, William Henry, Sir, 1862-1942 person
associatedWith Bragg, William Lawrence, Sir, 1890-1971 person
associatedWith Breit, Gregory, 1899-1981 person
associatedWith Brickwedde, F. G., (Ferdinand Graft), 1903-1989 person
associatedWith Briggs, George Henry person
associatedWith Brillouin, Leon, 1889-1969 person
associatedWith Brillouin, Marcel, 1854-1948 person
associatedWith Brill, Rudolf person
associatedWith Brinkelman, C. person
associatedWith Brinkman, Henri Coenraad person
associatedWith Brinsmade, James B., 1884-1936 person
associatedWith Broglie, Louis de, 1892-1987 person
associatedWith Brønsted, J. N., (Johannes Nicolaus), 1879-1947 person
associatedWith Bruce, Harold Lawton, 1887-1934 person
associatedWith Brück, H. A., (Hermann Alexander), 1905-2001 person
associatedWith Bruining, H. person
associatedWith Bruins, S. M. person
associatedWith Bruin, Take Luite de person
associatedWith Bruynzeel Deurenfabriek. corporateBody
associatedWith Bryan, G. H., (George Hartley), 1864-1928 person
associatedWith Bucherer, A. H., (Alfred Heinrich), b. 1863 person
associatedWith Buchwald, Eberhard, 1886-1975 person
associatedWith Burger, Herman Carel, 1893-1965. person
associatedWith Burgers, J. M., (Johannes Martinus), 1895-1981 person
associatedWith Burkhardt, Heinrich, 1861-1914 person
associatedWith Burns, Keivin, 1881-1958 person
associatedWith Burton, E. F., (Eli Franklin), b. 1879 person
associatedWith Bush, Vannevar, 1890-1974 person
associatedWith Cabrera, Blas, 1878-1945 person
associatedWith Campbell, E. C. person
associatedWith Campo, Angel del person
associatedWith Carathéodory, Constantin, 1873-1950 person
associatedWith Carslaw, H. S., (Horatio Scott), 1870-1954 person
associatedWith Carter, Ashley H., 1924-2008 person
associatedWith Casimir, H. B. G., (Hendrik Brugt Gerhard), 1909-2000 person
associatedWith Catalan, Miguel Angel, 1894-1957 person
associatedWith Chadwick, James, Sir, 1891-1974 person
associatedWith Champion, F. C., (Frank Clive) person
associatedWith Chapman, Sydney, 1888-1970 person
associatedWith Cherwell, Frederick Alexander Lindemann, Viscount, 1886-1957. person
associatedWith Christiansen, C., (Christian), 1843-1917 person
associatedWith Christiansen, Jens Anton, 1888-1969 person
associatedWith Christlein, Günther person
associatedWith Clarendon Laboratory. corporateBody
associatedWith Clay, Jacob, 1882-1955 person
associatedWith Clusius, Klaus, 1903-1963 person
associatedWith Cockcroft, John, Sir, 1897-1967 person
associatedWith Cohn, Emil, 1854-1944 person
associatedWith Colby, Walter F., (Walter Francis), 1880-1980 person
associatedWith College Entrance Examination Board. corporateBody
associatedWith Collins, E. H. person
associatedWith Columbia University. Men's Faculty Club. corporateBody
associatedWith Compton, Arthur Holly, 1892-1962 person
associatedWith Compton, Betty Charity McCloskey, 1916- person
associatedWith Compton, K. T., (Karl Taylor), 1887-1954 person
associatedWith Conant, James Bryant, 1893-1978 person
associatedWith Condon, Edward Uhler, 1902-1974. person
associatedWith Congresso internazionale dei fisici. corporateBody
associatedWith Cooper, Thomas, 1759-1839 person
associatedWith Cornelius, Hans, 1863-1947 person
associatedWith Correlli, A. person
associatedWith Coster, Dirk, 1889-1950 person
associatedWith Cotton, Aimé Auguste, 1869-1951 person
associatedWith Coues, Elliott, 1842-1899 person
associatedWith Courant, Richard, 1888-1972. person
associatedWith Craik, Kenneth James Williams person
associatedWith Cranz, Carl, 1858-1945 person
associatedWith Crawford, F. H., (Franzo Hazlett), b. 1900 person
associatedWith Cunningham, Ebenezer, 1881-1977 person
associatedWith Curie, Marie, 1867-1934 person
associatedWith Custers, Jan Frans Henri person
associatedWith Cuthbertson, Clive person
associatedWith Cuvier, Georges, Baron, 1769-1832 person
associatedWith Dahm, Thomas Matthew, b. 1887 person
associatedWith Dalla Noce, Giulio Cesare person
associatedWith Danmarks lærerhøjskole. corporateBody
associatedWith Dansk samfund i Holland, Amsterdam. corporateBody
associatedWith Dänzer-Vanotti, Hedda person
associatedWith Darlington, William, 1782-1863 person
associatedWith Darmstaedter, Ludwig, 1846-1927 person
associatedWith Darrow, Karl K. (Karl Kelchner), 1891- person
associatedWith Darwin, Charles Galton, Sir, 1887-1962 person
associatedWith David, Erwin person
associatedWith Davis, Bergen, 1869-1958 person
associatedWith Davis, Harvey N., (Harvey Nathaniel), b. 1881 person
associatedWith Davisson, Clinton Joseph, 1881-1958. person
associatedWith D. B. Centen, Uitgevers Maatschappij . corporateBody
associatedWith De Brún, Pádraig person
associatedWith Debye, Peter J. W. (Peter Josef William), 1884-1966. person
associatedWith De Jongh, C. M. J. person
associatedWith De Klerk, D. person
associatedWith Delbrück, Max person
associatedWith Delft Hogeschool Fonds. corporateBody
associatedWith Denier van der Gon, Hugo Anne Cornelis person
associatedWith Denmark. Udenrigsministeriet. corporateBody
associatedWith Dennison, David Mathias, 1900-1976 person
associatedWith Des Coudres, Theodor, 1862-1926 person
associatedWith Dessauer, Friedrich, 1881-1963 person
associatedWith Destouches, Jean-Louis person
associatedWith De Telegraaf. corporateBody
associatedWith Deutsches Museum. (Germany) corporateBody
associatedWith Diehl, Hermann D. person
associatedWith Dieke, Gerhard Heinrich, 1901-1965 person
associatedWith Diesselhorst, Hermann, 1870-1961 person
associatedWith Die Umschau. corporateBody
associatedWith Dijksterhuis, E. J., (Eduard Jan), 1892-1965 person
associatedWith Dirac, P. A. M., (Paul Adrien Maurice), 1902-1984 person
associatedWith Dmitriew, M. person
associatedWith Dolejsek, Vaclav person
associatedWith Dorgelo, Hendrik Berend, 1894-1961 person
associatedWith Döring, Werner, 1911-2006 person
associatedWith Dorn, E., (Ernst), 1848-1916 person
associatedWith Drude, Paul, 1863-1906 person
associatedWith Druyvesteyn, Mari Johan, 1901-1995 person
associatedWith Drygalski, Erich von, 1865-1949 person
associatedWith Duane, William, 1872-1935 person
associatedWith Du Bois, Henri Éduard Johan Godfried, 1863-1918 person
associatedWith DuBridge, Lee A., (Lee Alvin), 1901-1994 person
associatedWith Duffendack, Ora S., (Ora Stanley), b. 1890 person
associatedWith DuMond, Jesse W. M., (Jesse William Monroe), 1892-1976 person
associatedWith Dunham, J. L. person
associatedWith Dunning, John R., (John Ray), 1907-1975 person
associatedWith Durant, K. person
associatedWith Durnford, A. M. I. A. W., 1904-1994 person
associatedWith Dushman, Saul, b. 1883 person
associatedWith Duuren, Kars van person
associatedWith Dyck, Walther von, 1856-1934 person
associatedWith Eberhard, Gustav, b. 1867 person
associatedWith Ebert, Ludwig, 1894-1956 person
associatedWith Eckart, Carl, 1902-1973 person
associatedWith Eddington, Arthur Stanley, Sir, 1882-1944 person
associatedWith Edelstein, Ludwig, 1902-1965 person
associatedWith Edison, Thomas A., (Thomas Alva), 1847-1931 person
associatedWith Edlén, Bengt, 1906-1993 person
associatedWith Edwards, Charles William, 1873-1955 person
associatedWith Ehrenfest, Paul, 1880-1933. person
associatedWith Ehrenfest, Paul, 1915–1939 person
associatedWith Eilender, Walter, 1880-1959 person
associatedWith Einstein, Albert, 1879-1955. person
associatedWith Eitel, W., (Wilhelm), 1891-1979 person
associatedWith Ekman, Vagn Walfrid, 1874-1954 person
associatedWith Eldridge, John A., (John Adams), 1891-1970 person
associatedWith Elion, Leonard person
associatedWith Ellett, Alexander, 1894-1981 person
associatedWith Ellis, C. D., (Charles Drummond), 1895-1980 person
associatedWith Elsasser, Walter M., 1904-1991 person
associatedWith Elsevier Publishing Company. corporateBody
associatedWith Elwert, Gerhard person
associatedWith Emde, Fritz, 1873-1951 person
associatedWith Emergency Committee in Aid of Displaced Foreign Scholars corporateBody
associatedWith Emmelot, P., (Piet) person
associatedWith Enskog, David, 1884-1947 person
associatedWith Enzyklopädie der Mathematischen Wissenschaften. corporateBody
associatedWith Epstein, Paul Sophus, 1883-1966. person
associatedWith Errera, Jacques, 1906-1977 person
associatedWith Estermann, I., (Immanuel), 1900-1973 person
associatedWith Eucken, A., (Arnold), 1884-1950 person
associatedWith Euler, Hans von, 1873-1964 person
associatedWith Evans, Evan Jenkin, 1882-1944 person
associatedWith Everett, Edward, 1794-1865 person
associatedWith Ewald, Paul Peter, 1888-1985 person
associatedWith Excelsior Uitgeverij. corporateBody
associatedWith Faber, Georg, 1877-1966 person
associatedWith Fabry, Charles, 1867-1945 person
associatedWith Fajans, Kasimir, 1887-1975. person
associatedWith Fano, Ugo person
associatedWith Faxen, Olov Hilding, 1892-1970 person
associatedWith Feenberg, Eugene person
associatedWith Feenstra Kuiper, Pieter person
associatedWith Fermi, Enrico, 1901-1954. person
associatedWith Finkelnburg, Wolfgang, 1905-1967 person
associatedWith Fitch, John person
associatedWith Flanders, Sara person
associatedWith Fleischmann, Rudolf, 1903-2002 person
associatedWith Fleming, J. A., (John Adam), 1877-1956 person
associatedWith Fleming, J. A., Sir, (John Ambrose), 1849-1945 person
associatedWith Fleury, P., (Pierre) person
associatedWith Foëx, Gabriel person
associatedWith Fokker, A. D., (Adriaan Daniel), 1887-1972 person
associatedWith Foote, Paul D., (Paul Darwin), 1888-1971 person
associatedWith Föppl, Aug., (August), 1854-1924 person
associatedWith Forman, Paul person
associatedWith Fortrat, Rene, 1886-1966 person
associatedWith Foster, John Stuart, 1890-1944 person
associatedWith Fournier, G., (Georges) person
associatedWith Fowler, A., (Alfred), 1868-1940 person
associatedWith Fowler, R. H., (Ralph Howard), 1889-1944 person
associatedWith Fraenkel, Abraham Adolf, 1891-1965 person
associatedWith Frahm, Hermann person
associatedWith Frank, Nathaniel Herman, 1903-1984 person
associatedWith Frank, Philipp, 1884-1966 person
associatedWith Franz, Walter, 1911-1992 person
associatedWith Frauenfelder, Hans, 1922- person
associatedWith French, Charles Stacy, 1907- person
associatedWith Frenkel, Yakov Il'ich, 1894-1952 person
associatedWith Frerichs, Rudolf, 1901-1982 person
associatedWith Freundlich, B. person
associatedWith Fricke, Hugo, 1892-1972 person
associatedWith Fricke, Robert, 1861-1930 person
associatedWith Friedman, Herbert, 1916-2000. person
associatedWith Friedrich, Walter, 1883-1968 person
associatedWith Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität Berlin. corporateBody
associatedWith Frisch, Otto Robert, 1904- person
associatedWith Fröbe-Kapteyn, Olga person
associatedWith Fröhlich, H., (Herbert), 1905-1991 person
associatedWith Fues, Erwin Richard, 1893-1970 person
associatedWith Fürth, R., (Reinhold), 1893- person
associatedWith Gaboury, G. N. person
associatedWith Gaffron, H. (Hans) person
associatedWith Galbraith, Alan Stuart person
associatedWith Gamow, George, 1904-1968 person
associatedWith Gans, Richard, 1880-1954 person
associatedWith Garbasso, Antonio, 1871-1933 person
associatedWith Gärtner, Erna person
associatedWith Geendert person
associatedWith Geiger, Hans, 1882-1945 person
associatedWith Geitler, Jozef, (Jozef Karl Franz Otto Ritter) person
associatedWith Gell-Mann, Murray person
associatedWith Genootschap voor Wetenschappelijke Philosophie. corporateBody
associatedWith Genth, F. A., (Frederick Augustus), 1820-1893 person
associatedWith Gentile, Giovannino, 1906-1942 person
associatedWith Gentofte. (Denmark) corporateBody
associatedWith George, A. person
associatedWith Gerlach, Walther, 1889-1979. person
associatedWith Germany. Auswärtiges Amt. corporateBody
associatedWith Germer, Lester Halbert, 1896-1971 person
associatedWith Gerritsen, Alexander Nicolaas person
associatedWith Gerthsen, Christian, 1894-1956 person
associatedWith Gesellschaft Telefunken. corporateBody
associatedWith Ghosh, M. K. person
associatedWith Gibbs, R. C., (Roswell Clifton), b. 1878 person
associatedWith Gilles, J. person
associatedWith Glaser, Ludwig person
associatedWith Glocker, R. person
associatedWith Goldstein, Eugen, 1850-1930 person
associatedWith Gombás, P., (Pál), 1909-1971 person
associatedWith Gordon, Walter, 1893-1939 person
associatedWith Gorter, C. J., (Cornelius Jacobus), 1907-1980 person
associatedWith Götze, Raimund person
associatedWith Goucher, Frederick Shand, 1888-1973 person
associatedWith Goudsmit, Samuel Abraham, 1902-1978 person
associatedWith Gouweloos, M. L. person
associatedWith Govers, V. person
associatedWith Govindjee, 1932- person
associatedWith G. Ragoczy Buchhandel. corporateBody
associatedWith Granpré Molière, M. J., 1883-1972 person
associatedWith Gray, Asa, 1810-1888 person
associatedWith Greeley, Horace, 1811-1872 person
associatedWith Greenhill, G., Sir, (George), 1847-1927 person
associatedWith Green, Jerome Bowles, 1898-1960 person
associatedWith Greppi, Enrico, 1896-1969 person
associatedWith Grey, Arthur W. person
associatedWith Grimm, H. G. person
associatedWith Grinter, Linton E., (Linton Elias), b. 1902 person
associatedWith Groen, Pier person
associatedWith Groot, W. de person
associatedWith Groth, W., (Wilhelm) person
associatedWith Grotrian, Walter, 1890-1954 person
associatedWith Grüneisen, Eduard August, 1877-1949 person
associatedWith Gudden, Bernhard, 1892-1945 person
associatedWith Guggenheim, E. A., (Edward Armand), 1901-1970 person
associatedWith Guild of All Arts. corporateBody
associatedWith Guillemin, Victor, 1896-1985 person
associatedWith Gulbis, Fricis, 1891-1956 person
associatedWith Günther, M. person
associatedWith Gustafsen, T. person
associatedWith Haaff, P. van't person
associatedWith Haantjes, J., (Johannes) person
associatedWith Haar, D. ter person
associatedWith Haas, Arthur Erich, 1884-1941 person
associatedWith Haas, H. K. de person
associatedWith Haas, Wander Johannes de, 1878-1960 person
associatedWith Haber, Fritz, 1868-1934. person
associatedWith Haering, Theodor Lorenz, 1884-1964 person
associatedWith Haga, Hermanus, 1852-1936 person
associatedWith Hahn, Otto, 1879-1968. person
associatedWith Hale, George Ellery, 1868-1938. person
associatedWith Hall, Edwin Herbert, 1855-1938 person
associatedWith Hallo, H. person
associatedWith Halpern, Otto, 1899-1982 person
associatedWith Hamel, Georg, 1877-1954 person
associatedWith Hammer, Rudolf person
associatedWith Hancock, John M., (John Milton), 1883-1956 person
associatedWith Hanle, Wilhelm, 1901- person
associatedWith Hansen, H. M., (Hans Marius), 1886-1956 person
associatedWith Harding, Warren G. person
associatedWith Harms, Freidrich, 1876-1946 person
associatedWith Harnwell, G. P., (Gaylord Probasco), 1903-1982 person
associatedWith Harrison, George Russell, 1898-1979 person
associatedWith Hartmann, Hermann, 1914-1984 person
associatedWith Hartmann, Max, 1876-1962 person
associatedWith Hartogs, Friedrich, 1874-1943 person
associatedWith Hartree, Douglas R., (Douglas Rayner), 1897-1958 person
associatedWith Harvard University. corporateBody
associatedWith Harvard University. Milton Fund. corporateBody
associatedWith Hassé, Henry Ronald, b. 1884 person
associatedWith Hauser, Friedrich, 1883-1958 person
associatedWith Havinga, Egbert, 1909-1988 person
associatedWith Hayek, Friedrich A. von, (Friedrich August), 1899-1992 person
associatedWith Heckmann, G. person
associatedWith Heckmann, Otto, 1901-1983 person
associatedWith Hedrall, J. Arvid person
associatedWith Heilbron, John L. person
associatedWith Heilprin, Laurence B., 1906-1993 person
associatedWith Heisenberg, Werner, 1901-1976. person
associatedWith Heitler, Walter, 1904- person
associatedWith Heller, Gustav, 1866-1946 person
associatedWith Hemptinne, Marc de person
associatedWith Hemsalech, G. A., (Gustave Adolphe), b. 1875 person
associatedWith Henderson, George Hugh, 1892-1949 person
associatedWith Henneberg, Walter, 1910-1942 person
associatedWith Henning, Fritz, 1877-1958 person
associatedWith Henriques, Valdemar, 1864-1936 person
associatedWith Hepner, W. person
associatedWith Herglotz, Gustav, 1881-1953 person
associatedWith Hermann, Carl, 1898-1961 person
associatedWith Hermans, Petrus Hendrik, 1898-1979 person
associatedWith Hersey, Mayo Dyer, 1886-1978 person
associatedWith Hertz, Gustav, 1887- person
associatedWith Hertz, Paul, 1881-1940 person