Abbot, Francis Ellingwood, 1836-1903

Variant names

Hide Profile

American philosophical writer.

From the guide to the Francis Ellingwood Abbot letters, 1870-1885, (The New York Public Library. Manuscripts and Archives Division.)

F. E. Abbot received his A.B. from Harvard in 1859.

From the description of College themes and forensics, 1856-1857. (Harvard University). WorldCat record id: 77072877

Francis Ellingwood Abbot (1836-1903), was a Unitarian minister and a radical religious philosopher. Abbot founded the Free Religious Association (1867), was editor of the weekly publication The Index (1870-1880), and organizer and President of the National Liberal League. He earned an A.B. at Harvard University in 1855 and a Ph.D and A.M. in 1881. Abbot taught philosophy briefly at Harvard University in 1887.

From the description of Papers of Francis Ellingwood Abbot, 1841-1904. (Harvard University). WorldCat record id: 77071587

Born in Boston, Mass. Attended Harvard (A.B., 1859; Divinity School, 1859-1860; Ph.D., 1881); graduated Meadville Theological School (1863). Headmaster, girls' school, Meadville, Pa. (1860-1863). Minister, Dover, N.H. (1864-1869). Cofounder, Free Religious Association, 1867. Minister, First Independent Society, Toledo, Ohio (1869-1873). Editor, Index (1870-1880). Headmaster, boys' school, New York (1880-1881); boys' school, Cambridge, Mass. (1881-1892).

From the description of Papers of Francis Ellingwood Abbot, 1815-1940 (inclusive). (Harvard University, Divinity School Library). WorldCat record id: 182047348

Francis Ellingwood Abbot received his A.B. from Harvard in 1859.

From the description of Latin prose exercises : senior year, under Prof. W. W. Goodwin, 1858-1859. (Harvard University). WorldCat record id: 236231850

From the description of Mathematics papers, 1855. (Harvard University). WorldCat record id: 77072865

Francis Ellingwood Abbot (1836-1903) was a Unitarian minister and a radical religious philosopher. Abbot founded the Free Religious Association (1867), was editor of the weekly publication The Index (1870-1880), and organized and was President of the National Liberal League (1876).

Francis Ellingwood Abbot was born on November 6, 1836 in Boston, Massachusetts to Joseph Hale Abbot and Fanny Ellingwood (Larcom) Abbot. His father was a schoolmaster and amateur scientist. He had five siblings: Henry, Edwin, William, Edward, and Emily. The Abbot family stressed intellectual energy and vigor. From his father, Abbot inherited a respect for moral purity, while his mother taught him the virtues of religion. Abbot's personality was notably zealous as evidenced in his passionate love for his wife and in his avid attachment to his philosophical views.

Abbot attended the Boston Latin School from 1851 to 1854. He received a Bachelor of Arts degree from Harvard College in 1859, ranking number one in his class. During his college days, Abbot became a member of Phi Beta Kappa and the Harvard Chapel. More importantly, he fell in love with Katharine "Katie" Fearing Loring, and married her in secret in 1859. Although Abbot entered the Harvard Divinity School in November 1859, he did not stay long because Katie, with her parents, had moved to Minnesota. To be nearer to Katie, Abbot shifted his divinity studies to the Meadville Theological Seminary in Pennsylvania, graduating in 1863. It was at Meadville that Abbot, confronting the theory of evolution proposed by Charles Darwin, began to question his Unitarian faith. As a result of studying Darwin, Abbot decided to dedicate himself to a lifelong goal of anchoring religious faith to science and philosophy, rather than to revelation. With the publication of two articles in the North American Review (1864), Abbot established his reputation as a leading supporter Darwinism. Furthermore, he presented his own personal philosophical vision called Free Religion and rejected the notion of any religious authority, including that of Jesus Christ.

As the minister of the First Unitarian Society of Christians in Dover, New Hampshire, Abbot promoted his Free Religion philosophy. In 1866, he became an important figure in the debate at the Unitarian National Conference meeting at Syracuse, New York. There, Abbot challenged the idea that Unitarians should identify with Christianity. In addition, Abbot opposed a pledge of allegiance to "The Lord Jesus Christ" by Unitarians and declared his rejection of the authority of Jesus Christ as the Messiah. Abbot's radical views were rejected by the Conference. Increasingly alienated from mainstream Unitarian thought, Abbot helped organize the Free Religious Association in 1867 to provide a platform for the scientific study of religion, free from all creeds and ecclesiastical authority.

Abbot's radical religious views ruptured his relationship with his Dover congregation, and in 1868 he resigned his position. He then served as minister to a small break away group, the Independent Religious Society, from April to October 1868. When his association with this group ended, Abbot accepted a position as minister of the Unitarian Society of Toledo, Ohio, which, at his insistence, severed its connection with Unitarianism. However, this society was not successful and Abbot left in it 1873, signifying the end of Abbot's active participation in the Unitarian ministry.

In 1870, Abbot became the editor of The Index, a weekly publication dedicated to the advancement of Free Religion and secularism. Writing for The Index, Abbot campaigned for a purer and more genuine religion and became a national figure criticizing evangelical Protestantism and Roman Catholicism. Later in the 1870s, Abbot helped organize resistance to a proposed United States constitutional amendment that would declare the United States a Christian nation; he organized the movement by forming "liberal leagues." These leagues organized themselves into the National Liberal League and elected Abbot as their national President. Abbot's hostility to organized Christianity increased and he became committed to abolishing the political power of American Christianity and replacing it with the total secularization of society.

Prickly in nature and intolerant of other viewpoints, Abbot eventually broke with the National Liberal League over the anti-obscenity Comstock laws. By 1880, Abbot became exhausted championing liberal causes and Free Religion. Consequently, he resigned his leadership roles with The Index, the National Liberal League, and the Free Religious Association to devote more time to the formal study of philosophy. In 1881 he earned his Ph.D. in philosophy from Harvard University.

Unable to secure a teaching position because of his reputation for religious radicalism, Abbot earned a livelihood running a classical school for young men, the Home School for Boys in Cambridge, Massachusetts. In 1885, he published his first book, Scientific Theism, a critique of German idealistic philosophy. This work won wide attention in Europe and appeared in a German translation.

In 1887, Abbot finally secured a short-term teaching position at Harvard University as a replacement for Professor Josiah Royce in the Philosophy Department. However, this position later led to a public controversy when Abbot published his lectures as The Way Out of Agnosticism; Or, the Philosophy of Free Religion. Royce dismissed Abbot's philosophical positions as nonsense and charged Abbot with having limited scholastic abilities. Abbot sought public redress for Royce's comments by appealing to the Harvard Board of Overseers but was unsuccessful.

In 1892, Abbot received a legacy that allowed him to dedicate himself full-time to the study of philosophy. Unfortunately, tragedy struck the following year when Abbot's wife, Katie, died. Abbot, a devoted husband and father, was devastated by this sudden loss. He spent the last ten years of his life writing of Katie and composing a synthesis of his philosophical thought. His final work, The Syllogistic Philosophy, or Prolegomena to Science, was finished on September 29, 1903. Shortly after, on October 23, 1903, Abbot ended his own life at the grave site of his wife.

References used for this biography were:

Ahlstrom, Sydney and Robert Bruce Mullin. The Scientific Theist: A Life of Francis Ellingwood Abbot. Macon, Georgia:Mercer University Press,1987. Christie, Francis Albert.Francis Ellingwood Abbot.Dictionary of American Biography Base Set. American Council of Learned Societies, 1928-1936. Biography Resource Center. 7 June 2004. Francis Ellingwood Abbot. Religious Leaders of America, 2nd edition. The Gale Group, 1999. Biography Resource Center. 7 June 2004. Francis Ellingwood Abbot. Contemporary Authors Online, Gale 2004. Biography Resource Center. 7 June 2004. Mullen, Robert Bruce. Abbot, Francis Ellingwood;; American National Biography Online February 2000. Access Date: Monday February 23 11:19:53 EST 2004. Peden. W. Creighton.The Philosopher of Free Religion: Francis Ellingwood Abbot, 1836-1903.New York:Peter Lang Publishing, Inc., 1992.

From the guide to the Papers of Francis Ellingwood Abbot, 1841-1904., (Harvard University Archives)

Francis Ellingwood Abbot (1836-1903), son of Joseph Hale Abbot and Fanny Ellingwood Larcom, married Katharine F. Loring in 1859 and graduated from Harvard University with a bachelor of arts degree that same year. He attended Harvard Divinity School from 1859-1860, but did not graduate. He was awarded a degree in theology from Meadville Theological Seminary in Pennsylvania in 1863, and was ordained a Unitarian minister in Dover, New Hampshire in 1864. At the Unitarian conference in Syracuse in 1866 Abbot led a minority group who challenged the wording of the Unitarian constitution and preamble, claiming that it needed to be more liberal. The outcome of this dispute was the founding of the Free Religious Association in 1867.

The objectives of the Free Religious Association were to promote liberty of religious thought, increase humanitarian action and respect for reason, and to encourage a scientific study of theology. The organization attracted members from various Protestant denominations, especially from the Unitarians, as well as some non-Christian religions such as Judaism. Alongside Abbot, the original founders of this Association were William J. Potter, John Weiss, Dr. Cyrus A. Bartol, Edward C. Towne, and Octavius B. Frothingham. Abbot was editor of the Index, the publication of the Free Religious Association from 1870-1880. Abbot was also awarded a Ph.D. from Harvard University in 1881.

From the guide to the Abbot, Francis Ellingwood. Papers, 1815-1940., (Andover-Harvard Theological Library, Harvard Divinity School)

Archival Resources
Role Title Holding Repository
referencedIn James, William, 1842-1910. Papers, 1803-1941 (bulk: 1862-1910) Houghton Library
referencedIn Frothingham, Octavius Brooks, 1822-1895. The Assailants of Christianity (Celsus : Voltaire : Paine : Abbot) : concluding portion of the opening lecture in the tenth course of Sunday afternoon lectures in Horticultural Hall, Boston, January 6, 1878 / by Octavius Brooks Frothingham of New York City / copied by Miss Susie F. Loring from the original manuscript : manuscript, 1878 Feb. 12. Houghton Library
referencedIn Abbot, Edwin Hale, 1834-1927. Edwin Hale Abbot family papers, 1787-1933 (inclusive). Yale University Library
creatorOf Abbot, Francis Ellingwood, 1836-1903. Papers of Francis Ellingwood Abbot, 1841-1904. Harvard University, Archives
referencedIn Norton, Charles Eliot, 1827-1908. Papers, ca.1845-1908 Houghton Library
referencedIn Letters from various correspondents, 1897-1904. Houghton Library
referencedIn Sumner, William Graham, 1840-1910. William Graham Sumner papers, 1863-1946 (inclusive). Yale University Library
creatorOf Ricketson, Anna, 1836-1927,. Letters from various correspondents, 1897-1904. Houghton Library
creatorOf Abbot, Francis Ellingwood. Papers, 1815-1940. Andover-Harvard Theological Library
referencedIn Wright, Elizur, 1804-1885. Elizur Wright papers, 1793-1935 (bulk 1830-1885). Library of Congress
creatorOf Abbot, Francis Ellingwood, 1836-1903. Francis Ellingwood Abbot. Photograph collection, 1848-1904. Harvard University, Divinity School Library
referencedIn Edwin Hale Abbot family papers, 1787-1933 Yale University. Department of Manuscripts and Archives
creatorOf Abbot, Francis Ellingwood, 1836-1903. Latin prose exercises : senior year, under Prof. W. W. Goodwin, 1858-1859. Harvard University, Archives
creatorOf Francis Ellingwood Abbot letters, 1870-1885 New York Public Library. Manuscripts and Archives Division
referencedIn North American Review, papers, ca.1842-1868. Houghton Library
creatorOf Abbot, Francis Ellingwood, 1836-1903. Mathematics papers, 1855. Harvard University, Archives
referencedIn Houghton Library printed book provenance file, A-D Houghton Library
referencedIn Elizur Wright Papers, 1793-1935, (bulk 1830-1885) Library of Congress. Manuscript Division
referencedIn Abbot, Francis Ellingwood. Papers, 1815-1940. Andover-Harvard Theological Library
referencedIn Thayer, William Roscoe, 1859-1923. Papers, 1762-1927 (bulk 1872-1921) Houghton Library
creatorOf Scudder, Horace Elisha, 1838-1902. Letters received, 1876-1877. Boston Athenaeum
referencedIn Allen, Joseph Henry, 1820-1898. Correspondence, 1842-1897 (inclusive). Harvard University, Divinity School Library
referencedIn Autograph File, A, 1518-2002. Houghton Library
creatorOf Abbot, Francis Ellingwood, 1836-1903. Papers of Francis Ellingwood Abbot, 1815-1940 (inclusive). Harvard University, Divinity School Library
creatorOf Abbot, Francis Ellingwood, 1836-1903. College themes and forensics, 1856-1857. Harvard University, Archives
referencedIn Abbot, Francis Ellingwood. Papers, 1815-1940. Andover-Harvard Theological Library
referencedIn Gannett, Lewis, 1891-1966. Papers, 1681-1966 (bulk 1900-1960) Houghton Library
creatorOf Papers of Francis Ellingwood Abbot, 1841-1904. Harvard University Archives.
referencedIn Soldiers' Memorial Society. Records, 1864-1878 (inclusive). Harvard University, Divinity School Library
referencedIn Correspondence and other papers, 1831-1891. Houghton Library
Role Title Holding Repository
Relation Name
associatedWith Abbot, Edwin Hale, 1834-1927. person
correspondedWith Abbot, Fanny person
correspondedWith Abbot, Francis Ellingwood, 1836-1903 person
correspondedWith Abbot, Katharine person
correspondedWith Abbot, Stanley person
associatedWith Alcott, A. B. person
associatedWith Allen, Joseph Henry, 1820-1898. person
correspondedWith American Bible Society corporateBody
associatedWith American Secular Union. corporateBody
associatedWith American Trust for the Publication of Free Thought. corporateBody
associatedWith American Trust for the Publication of Liberal Thought. corporateBody
associatedWith Ames, Isaac person
associatedWith Anthony Comstock person
associatedWith Anti-Imperialist League corporateBody
associatedWith Augell, F. A. person
associatedWith Bergh, Henry person
associatedWith Besant, Annie person
associatedWith Biltcliffe, Jonathan person
correspondedWith B. O. Flower person
associatedWith Bowditch, H. P. person
associatedWith Bowditch, W. J. person
associatedWith Bowers, Francis person
associatedWith Bradlaugh, Charles person
associatedWith Britten, Emma Harding person
associatedWith Burleigh, C. C. person
associatedWith Calderwood, Henry person
associatedWith Cary, George L. person
associatedWith Chandler, C. F. person
correspondedWith Charles L. Minot person
associatedWith Child, F. J. person
associatedWith Child, Le Maria person
associatedWith Choate, Joseph person
associatedWith Claflin, F. L. person
associatedWith Clark, Peter H. person
associatedWith Coble, Francis person
correspondedWith Col. T. W. Higginson person
associatedWith Comstock, Anthony person
associatedWith Conway, Moncure Daniel person
associatedWith Cooke, Josiah P. person
associatedWith Cutler, E. J. person
associatedWith Dall, Caroline H. person
associatedWith Davis, Andrew Jackson person
associatedWith Davis, Mary F. person
associatedWith Dix, Dorothea Lynde, 1802-1887. person
associatedWith Dix, John A. person
correspondedWith Dorothea Dix person
associatedWith Douglass, Samuel T. person
associatedWith E. C. Towne person
correspondedWith Edwin Abbot person
correspondedWith Emily Balch person
associatedWith E. Stanley Abbot person
associatedWith Evans, Frederick W. person
correspondedWith Everett V. Abbot person
correspondedWith Fanny Abbot person
associatedWith Fanny Ellingwood Abbot person
correspondedWith F. E. Abbot person
associatedWith First Independent Society of Dover corporateBody
associatedWith Forbes, J. M. person
associatedWith Forlong, James George Roche person
associatedWith Foster, Abbey Kelly person
correspondedWith F.R.A. corporateBody
correspondedWith Frances Lewis Smith Abbot person
associatedWith Free Religious Association corporateBody
associatedWith Free Religious Association (Boston, Mass.) corporateBody
associatedWith Frothingham, Octavius Brooks, 1822-1895. person
correspondedWith Gannett, Lewis, 1891-1966 person
associatedWith Garrison, William Lloyd person
associatedWith Gauney, E. W. person
associatedWith Gladstone, W. E. person
associatedWith Gladstone, William E. person
associatedWith Goodwin, William Watson, 1831-1912. person
associatedWith Goodwin, W. W. person
associatedWith Graham, Allen D. person
associatedWith Gray, John C. person
associatedWith Greeley, Horace person
associatedWith Grosbuck, D. person
associatedWith Harrison, E. L. person
associatedWith Harris, T. L. person
associatedWith Harvard corporateBody
associatedWith Harvard Divinity School corporateBody
associatedWith Harvard University corporateBody
associatedWith Haven, Joseph person
associatedWith Heinze, M. person
associatedWith Henry David Thoreau. person
correspondedWith Henry James person
correspondedWith Henry L. Abbot person
associatedWith Hickok, L. P. person
associatedWith Higginson, Thomas Wentworth, 1823-1911. person
associatedWith Hoadly, George person
associatedWith Holyoake, George Jacob person
associatedWith Hopps, John Page person
associatedWith Hosmer, James K. person
associatedWith Houghton Library. corporateBody
associatedWith Index Association. corporateBody
associatedWith James, Henry, 1811-1882. person
correspondedWith James, William, 1842-1910 person
associatedWith Johnson, Oliver person
correspondedWith John Witt Randall person
associatedWith Jones, J. H. person
associatedWith Joseph Hale Abbot person
associatedWith Judge, Mark H. person
correspondedWith Katharine Abbot person
correspondedWith Katharine F. Abbot person
associatedWith Kent, Austin person
associatedWith Liberal Union Club of Boston. corporateBody
associatedWith Linton, E. D. person
associatedWith Massachusetts State Archives corporateBody
associatedWith Maxse, Frederick person
associatedWith May, S. J. person
associatedWith McKim person
associatedWith Mill, John Stuart person
associatedWith Minor, G. G. person
associatedWith Morley, John person
associatedWith Morton, C. E. person
associatedWith Mott, Lucretia person
correspondedWith Mrs. L. L. Buss person
associatedWith Müller, F. Max person
associatedWith Nathan Dane. person
associatedWith National Liberal League. corporateBody
associatedWith National Liberal League of America corporateBody
associatedWith Newman, Francis W. person
associatedWith North American Review. corporateBody
associatedWith Northhall, Victoria person
associatedWith Norton, Charles Eliot, 1827-1908 person
associatedWith Nute, E. person
correspondedWith O. B. Frothingham person
associatedWith Old Planters Society corporateBody
associatedWith Oliver, Henry K. person
associatedWith Orton, Edward person
associatedWith Orvis, John person
associatedWith Owen, Robert Dale person
associatedWith Parris, Touzeau person
correspondedWith Parton, James, 1822-1891 person
associatedWith Peabody, Elizabeth person
associatedWith Peebles, J. M. person
correspondedWith Philip Stanley Abbot.) person
associatedWith Phillips, Wendell, 1811-1884. person
associatedWith Pierce, Benjamin person
associatedWith Post, Amy person
associatedWith Radical Club of Toledo. corporateBody
associatedWith Ricketson, Anna, 1836-1927, person
associatedWith Robert Ingersoll person
associatedWith Rodman, Benjamin person
associatedWith Rogers, William B. person
associatedWith Roosevelt, Clinton person
associatedWith Sarah. person
associatedWith Schmidt, G. A. person
associatedWith Schonfeld, H. person
associatedWith Scott, Thomas person
associatedWith Scudder, Horace Elisha, 1838-1902. person
associatedWith Sen, Keshub Chunder person
associatedWith Smith, Elizabeth Oakes person
associatedWith Smith, Gerrit person
associatedWith Soldiers' Memorial Society. corporateBody
associatedWith Spencer, Herbert person
associatedWith Spooner, L. person
correspondedWith Stanley Abbot person
associatedWith Stanton, Elizabeth Cady person
associatedWith Stearns, Oliver S. person
associatedWith Stevenson, F. P. person
associatedWith Sullivan, William L. (William Laurence), 1872-1935. person
associatedWith Sumner, William Graham, 1840-1910. person
associatedWith Sunderland, Laroy person
associatedWith Supreme Court corporateBody
associatedWith Susan Loring person
associatedWith Thayer, A. P. person
correspondedWith Thayer, William Roscoe, 1859-1923 person
associatedWith The Index Stockholders Association corporateBody
associatedWith The Latin School corporateBody
associatedWith Tilton, Theodore person
associatedWith Tuttle, Hudson person
correspondedWith T. W. Higginson person
associatedWith Tyndall, John person
associatedWith Upham, Thomas person
associatedWith Voysey, Charles person
associatedWith Wallace, Alfred person
associatedWith Warren, Josiah person
associatedWith Warren, William F. person
associatedWith Washington, Booker T., 1856-1915. person
associatedWith Watts, Charles person
correspondedWith Wendell Phillips person
associatedWith Wendlandt, Wilhelm person
associatedWith Whipple, H. B. person
associatedWith Wilton family
associatedWith Woodhull, Victoria person
correspondedWith Wright, Elizur, 1804-1885. person
associatedWith Young's Hotel corporateBody
associatedWith Zakrzewska, M. E. person
associatedWith Zeller person
Place Name Admin Code Country
United States
Theology--Study and teaching (Higher)
Liberalism (Religion)
Religion in the public schools
Philosophy--United States
Religion and science
Religion and politics
Philosophy--Study and teaching (Higher)
Free thought


Birth 1836-11-06

Death 1903-10-23





Ark ID: w65b07q4

SNAC ID: 28950783