Grace Episcopal Church was established in the Diocese of Central New York in 1870. The first church building was a simple wooden structure at the corner of Madison Street and University Avenue. This was replaced in 1876 by a limestone edifice which is still in use. In 1916, the church added a parish house, and in 1940 the two upper stories of the tower were removed; otherwise, the structure designed by architect Horatio Nelson White remains much the same.
- Thomas E. Pattison, 1870-1886
- Horace Gates, 1887
- John T. Rose, 1888-1890
- Herbert G. Coddington, 1891-1931
- Charles Paterson-Smyth, 1931-1937
- Bradford H. Tite, 1937-1942
- James Rockwell, 1942-1968
- William C. Hicks, 1948-1949
- Walter N. Welsh, 19449-
From the guide to the Grace Episcopal Church (Syracuse NY) Records, 1870-1966, (Special Collections Research Center, Syracuse University Libraries)